Tuesday, July 29, 2008

Twist in sodomy saga

PETALING JAYA: Police have slammed a news portal report, which claimed that a private hospital doctor who had examined Mohd Saiful Bukhari Azlan had been arrested.
Deputy Inspector General of Police Tan Sri Ismail Omar said the articles were just another attempt by certain quarters to confuse the public over the on-going investigation into Mohd Saiful's police report alleging that he had been sodomised by PKR adviser Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim.
The online articles posted a medical report which said there was “zero active bleeding”, “zero ulcer or pus” and “zero tear and scar” in Mohd Saiful’s anus.
The report from Pusrawi Hospital was signed by Dr Mohamed Osman Abdul Hamid at 2.14pm on June 28.
Malaysia Today editor Raja Petra Kamaruddin, who also carried the report on his website, said this proved that Mohd Saiful was not sodomised by Opposition de facto leader Anwar.
“The police also have a copy of this report that I have published, so they know what I know,” he wrote.
Raja Petra also alleged that Dr Mohamed Osman had gone into hiding because the police wanted him to change his medical report to implicate Anwar.
“There is no truth to these allegations," said the Deputy IGP.
"In fact we interviewed the aforementioned doctor in the early stages of our investigation following the report lodged by Saiful.
“Neither did we arrest the doctor or detain him for three days as alleged in the Malaysia Today article. We do not have any plans to do so either,” Ismail said, declining to comment further.
PKR secretary-general Salehuddin Hashim said there needed to be a complete public disclosure of the facts of the case.
“The medical report appears to confirm what we have always believed – that the allegations against Anwar are without merit and are politically motivated.”
DAP adviser Lim Kit Siang said: “This is a very disturbing turn of developments and will subject Malaysia to a new spate of international bashing unless the police can come forward to throw light on the first medical report and the whereabouts of Dr Mohamed Osman.”
How the medical report was leaked, which is a breach of patient confidentiality, is unknown, but Health Minister Datuk Liow Tiong Lai said the Malaysian Medical Council must look into the case.
A top Health Ministry official said the leaked report was probably not a full report because it appeared to be documenting only the superficial.
A spokesperson from the hospital said a statement would be issued soon.

tunku : so it is a twist in sodomy saga, well not really. till now we can't confirm that the medical report is real and not tempered with. the police need to speed up their investigation.they can't hold for long as it will give negative impact on the case.saiful need to sue the hospital(pusrawi) for disclosing the report whether it's true or false one.saiful's lawyer need to make a statement on this matter too.it's still not clear so don't jump into conclusion that anwar the moron is innocent.we have to check with hkl report first as according the news on the internet saiful did not tell the doctor he was sodomized but told the doctor that he was assaulted by the intrusion of a piece of "plastic" in the anus.so let us wait.

13 comments:

HeroTamil said...

K....may be true, but still does not the question raised by mR PUNAI himself, Siapa Rogol siapa, not denying SOMETHING did happen!!

Sepul did it to him then?? Y didnt PUNAI Report it?? a willing victim??

hmmmmmmm...........

Anonymous said...

hero tamil

apa pasal lu mencarut....tak malu ka. Anyway, RPK will try all sorts of tactics including digging here and there and looks like he knows what Saiful did prior to the HKL check up think somebody who knows saiful has been bought by him. As usual he will create the drama because the real report should come fr HKL. I will not buy the story yet till the PUSRAWEI can clear the real air.Meantime the Anwar camp will be celebrating but not for long...Police is going still investigating.Truth will prevail.

Anonymous said...

Dear Tunku,

Bagi saya ia bukanlah 'zero' tapi ia adalah 'bullet point' bila kita buat presentation. Ini bermaksud dalam pemeriksaan doktor itu memang ada bukti sahih.

Anonymous said...

yang tu zero atau persen????? kalau doctor selalu tulis NIL kan atau pun straight NO..

Anonymous said...

Dear mbms (nasib baik bukan mbbs - medical degree),

Jika kita amati tulisan Dr dalam report kita di klinik/hospital, bullet point hanya ditulis sebagai "-" dan bukan "o".

Tak Dak Nama 3

Kerel Bort said...

taken this from husin lempoyang blog.. one of my fav blog.. one of the commenter comment sound like this
_____________________
ayor_lemuju said...

yg didakwa 0 (zero) active bleeding, 0 ulcer or puss seen dan 0 tear seen. tu bukan zero tapi "o" maksudnya observation. Kependekan untuk tiada ialah null, no, neg(ative) atau -/ve

Diagnosis: TRO Assault (sodomise)
Rawatan: advise to go to the government hospital (plan to do police report)

Ini bermaksud doktor mengesahkan Saiful telah diliwat dan menggesa Saiful memohon Temporary Restraining Order (TRO), dengan mendapat pemeriksaan di hospital kerajaan seterusnya membuat laporan polis.

Dipetik dari satu website:-
An employer may not discharge, discriminate, or retaliate against an employee who is a domestic violence/sexual assault survivor for taking time off to:
* Obtain/attempt to obtain any relief, including a TRO/RO/injunctive relief, to help insure the health, safety, or welfare of a survivor
________________________________

which to me make sense.. since when the medical staff using 0 which easily confuse with o

Anonymous said...

dah bermacam plak spekulasi keluar tentang laporan perubatan yang dibocorkan tu.mana taknya,ingat senang ke nak faham tulisan doktor ditambah lagi dengan ayat-ayat kedoktoran tu.maksud "o" tu pun dah banyak yang keliru.ada yang kata "oberservation",bullet point for presentation,ada yang kata percentage.pening-pening.

lagi satu,kenapa saiful diminta untuk check kat HKL selepas itu?.dalam laporan polis juga ada menyatakan bahawa Saiful tak dedahkan sapa yang ehemehem dia masa buat medical cek up kat private hospital tu.

Anonymous said...

a twist it is indeed. but it has the same style of other RPK explosive expose. Like the SDs and the reliable informants of his. Suddenly plonk down a medical report there. And now the doctor gone to hiding. It's like a script from a drama.

Anonymous said...

Again, RPK has come out a new shocking article regarding to Anwar’s latest sodomy case. But should the medical report be reveal out so easy? Medical report are confidential anyway..how does RPK has clean hands on this source? Is the source reliable? It might be like the previous SD he made earlier.

More curiously, why the police has to chase after the missing doctor? would that be more easy if the authorities just need to find a replacement instead?

Is the doctor an expert proven by authorities to check on him? Why did the doctor ran and hide? Why detain the police detain the doctor? If I am DSAI being accused of this and my political career at stake and with my money and my connection I can buy anyone or anything to do my bid or to lie for me! Wouldn't you?!

further more, more speculations arise from the report itself. Some claims the writings could be very confusing, which therefore reflects the trustworthy of this source revealed out.

But in a conclusion, when it comes to political cases it would never be solve in a short period. The actual truth will never leak out to public.

Da Real Deal said...

Apa yang polis lambat sangat siasat? Dah sebulan lebih bontot budak tu di usik. Polis pun macam kerajaan jugak...half past six!

Anonymous said...

after the emerged of the medical report, people started to tap into their doctor-instinct to decipher the report. The result? a few different diagnosis from many sudden-established doctors in our country.
Instead of making millions guesses, why can't we just give it a rest, take a step back and see the case in a neutral p.o.v.

Anonymous said...

Wow! Kalaulah TRO dalam medical report bermakna "Temporary Restraining Order", maknanya ada istilah undang2 dalam medical report!

Tak Dak Nama 3

Anonymous said...

Kita tak tahu yang medical report itu yang asal atau tidak. Ada kemungkinan bukti2 yang dikemukakan itu direka. Atau mungkin laporan asal sudah di ubah. Jangan terlalu cepat membuat andaian berdasarkan apa yang orang cakap.